hnlzm@lvmeikapton.com
+86 13787123465
Hunan Lvzhimei New Material Technology Co., Ltd.

What Are the Critical Differences Between Adhesive PET and PI Tapes for High-Temp Apps? |https://www.lvmeikapton.com/

Source: | Author:Koko Chan | Published time: 2025-07-25 | 16 Views | Share:


What Are the Critical Differences Between Adhesive PET and PI Tapes for High-Temp Apps?
1. Introduction1.1 Importance of High-Temperature ApplicationsHigh-temperature environments are prevalent across industries, demanding materials with exceptional resilience. Aerospace applications, such as jet engine components, operate at temperatures exceeding 1,000°C, necessitating materials that withstand thermal stress without degradation. In petrochemical industries, equipment used for oil refining and gas processing face prolonged exposure to temperatures above 200°C, requiring resistance to both heat and corrosive chemicals. Electronics manufacturing, particularly in semiconductor fabrication, relies on processes like soldering (260-350°C) and thermal cycling tests, which demand materials that maintain stability during repeated thermal shocks. Automotive engines and exhaust systems, operating at 150-800°C, pose stringent requirements for thermal insulation and mechanical integrity. Additionally, emerging technologies like solar thermal energy conversion and high-temperature batteries further expand the need for advanced thermal-resistant materials. The performance of these applications hinges on the reliability of components, emphasizing the criticality of selecting materials capable of withstanding extreme conditions.
1.2 Key Role of Selecting the Right High-Temperature TapeThe choice of high-temperature tape directly impacts equipment reliability, product quality, and safety. For instance, in automotive wiring harnesses, inadequate tape selection can lead to insulation failure, short circuits, or fire hazards. In electronics assembly, incorrect tape usage during wave soldering (peak temperatures >300°C) may result in tape melting, adhesive residue contamination, or circuit board delamination. Conversely, high-performance tapes like PI (Polyimide) offer superior thermal stability, ensuring consistent insulation and mechanical retention even during reflow processes. Moreover, appropriate tape selection extends equipment lifespan, reducing maintenance costs and downtime. For example, in aerospace applications, where replacement costs for failed components can reach millions of dollars, the use of tapes with validated thermal endurance is non-negotiable. Ultimately, tape selection is a pivotal decision balancing performance, safety, and economic feasibility.
2. Basic Characteristics of PI and PET Tapes2.1 PI Tape: Chemical Structure, Manufacturing, and PropertiesPI tape is fabricated from Polyimide (PI) film, a thermosetting polymer derived from aromatic dianhydrides (e.g., PMDA) and diamines (e.g., ODA or p-PDA). Its backbone consists of rigid aromatic rings and imide groups (-CO-NR-CO-), imparting exceptional thermal and chemical resistance. The manufacturing process involves synthesizing polyamic acid (PAA) solution via step polymerization, followed by casting, thermal imidization (200-400°C), and adhesive coating. Key properties include:
● 
Thermal Stability: Continuous operation up to 260°C, short-term resistance to 400°C.
● 
Chemical Resistance: Immune to acids, solvents, and oils.
● 
Electrical Properties: High dielectric strength (≥200 kV/mm), low dielectric constant (3.4 at 1 MHz).
● 
Mechanical Strength: Tensile strength >200 MPa at 20°C, retaining >100 MPa at 200°C. Notable commercial grades include DuPont Kapton (biaxially oriented) and Ube Industries Upilex (enhanced thermal stability).
2.2 PET Tape: Chemical Structure, Manufacturing, and PropertiesPET tape is based on Polyethylene Terephthalate (PET) film, synthesized by polycondensation of terephthalic acid and ethylene glycol. Its linear aliphatic structure provides flexibility and mechanical toughness. Production involves melt extrusion, uniaxial stretching (yielding high molecular orientation), and adhesive application. Key features are:
● 
Temperature Range: -70°C to 150°C continuous use.
● 
Mechanical Durability: High tensile strength (≥150 MPa) and excellent tear resistance.
● 
Electrical Insulation: Suitable for general-purpose applications (dielectric strength ≈20 kV/mm).
● 
Cost Efficiency: Lower raw material and processing costs compared to PI. Common applications include cable wrapping, general electrical insulation, and low-temperature packaging.
3. Comparison of Temperature Resistance3.1 Maximum Continuous Operating Temperature
Tape Type
Continuous Use Temperature
Short-Term Exposure
Key Limitations
PI Tape
260°C
Up to 400°C for hours
None at specified temps
PET Tape
150°C
Melts at >180°C
Degradation above 150°C
This disparity is crucial: while PET tapes suffice for oven insulation (e.g., household appliances), PI tapes are essential for high-reliability sectors like aerospace, where engine compartments reach 250°C. For example, during electronics reflow soldering (peak 350°C), PI tape remains stable, while PET tape would degrade, risking component failure.
3.2 Durability and Thermal Shock ResistancePI tape exhibits remarkable long-term stability, retaining >80% mechanical strength after 10,000 hours at 250°C. Conversely, PET tape strength declines rapidly above 120°C, with significant degradation observed after 500 hours at 150°C. Additionally, PI tape withstands rapid thermal cycling (-70°C to 300°C) without cracking or delamination, a critical feature for automotive underhood components exposed to extreme diurnal temperature fluctuations.
4. Adhesive Performance Analysis4.1 Performance of Silicone Adhesive at Different TemperaturesSilicone adhesives are commonly used for both PI and PET tapes. Their performance varies with temperature:
● 
<150°C: Stable adhesion, maintaining peel strength >10 N/25 mm.
● 
150-200°C: Gradual strength reduction (20-30% loss).
● 
>200°C: Significant softening, adhesive bleed, and bond failure. However, modified silicone systems with ceramic fillers or fluoropolymers can enhance high-temperature retention.
4.2 Comparison of Adhesive Stability between PI and PET Tapes
Tape Type
Adhesive Retention at 200°C
Adhesive Creep at 250°C
PI Tape
>90% initial strength after 1,000 hrs
Minimal creep (≤5% deformation)
PET Tape
50-70% strength retention at 500 hrs
Significant creep (≥20% deformation)
This disparity is exacerbated in dynamic environments: PET tape adhesive may detach under thermal expansion/contraction cycles, while PI tape maintains firm bonding.
5. Other Performance Indicators5.1 Dimensional Stability at High TemperaturesPI tape’s rigid molecular structure ensures <1% dimensional change at 300°C, enabling precise component positioning in aerospace assemblies. PET tape, however, exhibits 3-5% shrinkage at 150°C, compromising its suitability for critical alignment applications.
5.2 Dielectric Properties at Elevated Temperatures
Property
PI Tape (260°C)
PET Tape (150°C)
Dielectric Strength
150 kV/mm
10 kV/mm
Tan δ (1 kHz)
<0.02
0.05-0.08
PI tape’s superior dielectric stability prevents arcing or insulation breakdown in high-voltage environments, such as electric vehicle battery packs.
6. Practical Application Examples6.1 Electronics Manufacturing: Soldering and AssemblyDuring lead-free soldering (peak 380°C), PI tape protects components from thermal damage. A case study at Foxconn’s electronics plant revealed that PI tape reduced solder-related defects by 95% compared to PET tape, which melted and caused circuit contamination.
6.2 Automotive Industry: Engine and Exhaust System ComponentsPI tape is used for wire harness insulation in engine compartments (avg. temp 200°C). Volkswagen’s Audi R8 engine harnesses utilize PI tape, ensuring 10-year durability, while PET tape alternatives failed within 2 years due to cracking and adhesive detachment.
6.3 Aerospace: Extreme Thermal EnvironmentsNASA’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory specified PI tape (Kapton HN) for the Mars Rover’s thermal control systems, enduring Martian temperature extremes (-125°C to 70°C) and radiation exposure. PET tape was disqualified due to insufficient thermal cycling performance.
7. Cost-Effectiveness Analysis7.1 Cost Comparison: Production and Market PricingPI tape’s costs are 3-5x higher than PET tape due to:
● 
Raw material costs: PI film’s specialty monomers vs. PET’s commodity precursors.
● 
Complex manufacturing: Imidization requires high-energy processes and solvent recovery systems.
● 
Lower production yields (5-10% vs. PET’s 20-30%).
7.2 Performance-to-Cost Ratio in Different Scenarios
● 
Low-Temp, Cost-Sensitive Apps: PET tape excels for household appliance wiring (≤120°C) or temporary thermal protection.
● 
High-Temp, Mission-Critical Apps: PI tape’s longevity and reliability offset upfront costs. For example, a 5,000PItapeinvestmentinaturbinegeneratormaysave5,000 PI tape investment in a turbine generator may save50,000 in maintenance over 5 years vs. PET tape replacements.
8. Conclusion8.1 Summary of Key Differences
1. 
Temperature Range: PI (260°C continuous) vs. PET (150°C max).
2. 
Adhesive Durability: PI retains strength >200°C, PET degrades above 150°C.
3. 
Dimensional Stability: PI <1% change at 300°C, PET 3-5% at 150°C.
4. 
Electrical Performance: PI’s dielectric strength 15x higher than PET at elevated temps.
5. 
Cost: PI is premium-priced but economically viable for high-reliability applications.
8.2 Selection Guidelines for Various Applications
● 
Aerospace, Electronics Soldering, High-Voltage Systems: Prioritize PI tape for guaranteed thermal and electrical safety.
● 
Automotive (underhood <150°C), General Industrial Insulation: PET tape offers cost-effective performance.
● 
Dynamic Thermal Environments: Always select PI tape to avoid adhesive failure and dimensional drift.
Table: Comparative Summary of PI vs. PET Tapes
Aspect
PI Tape
PET Tape
Max Temp (Continuous)
260°C
150°C
Adhesive Type
Silicone + modified systems (high-temp retention)
Standard silicone (limited >150°C)
Dimensional Stability
≤1% change at 300°C
3-5% shrinkage at 150°C
Dielectric Strength
150 kV/mm (260°C)
10 kV/mm (150°C)
Cost per Unit
5−5-20/m²
1−1-3/m²
Recommended Uses
Aerospace, electronics reflow, high-voltage systems
Cable management, low-temp insulation, temporary fixes
In summary, while PET tape offers cost advantages for moderate-temperature applications, PI tape’s unparalleled thermal, mechanical, and electrical properties are indispensable for technologies operating at the forefront of human progress. Selecting the appropriate tape is not merely a material choice—it is a strategic decision safeguarding performance, safety, and long-term economic viability.